Tom Sykes
How groups move forward when nobody knows the answer

Things I think are true

Groups rarely stall for lack of information. They stall because honesty and commitment cost more than drift. Seven arguments that follow from that. Revised when I’m proven wrong.

  1. Group dynamics

    1. Most bad decisions are social, not analytical.

    In a group, the right answer is rarely missing. Someone in the room usually has it. What’s missing is the willingness to say it at the cost of a relationship or a position. I call this social discounting: the gap between the decision we’d make alone with the data and the one we make together. Every governance structure assumes it isn’t there. I’ve done it myself in board meetings. It can’t be removed, only managed. The job is to price it in, not pretend it away.

  2. Decisions

    2. Business is poker, not chess.

    Governance assumes decisions are computable: do enough analysis and the right move appears. Most aren’t. They’re bets made with incomplete information, against other players, under social pressure. That changes how you should judge them. A good decision can lose and a bad one can win, so judge the process and keep score over time. I write my predictions down before the event for exactly that reason, and once a year I invite everyone else to do the same.

  3. Machines join the group

    3. AI assistants will end experience as a moat.

    AI assistants will answer the question and complete the purchase without anyone visiting your site. That quietly strips out three things experience-led businesses depend on: the customer data, the direct relationship, and the upsell built into the interface. Chocolate might still be positioned next to the checkout, but there’s no one to be tempted. Information businesses go first; where the journey is the point, as in healthcare or luxury, it holds longer. Everyone else faces a prisoner’s dilemma: cooperate with the assistants or defend the walled garden. Decide before the choice is made for you.

  4. Strategy

    4. Plans rarely fail in the room. They fail on the way out of it.

    Most strategies are sound enough on the day they’re agreed. What goes wrong is the gap between intent and action. People read the plan differently, conditions change, and nobody knows how far they’re allowed to adapt. The fix isn’t a more detailed plan. It’s a clearer intent, and more freedom to act on it. Groups move forward when people know what matters and are trusted to work out the how.

    Behind this The Art of Action
  5. Between groups

    5. Information asymmetry is a design problem, not a negotiating tactic.

    In cloud and digital deals, the vendor usually knows far more about how you’ll use the service than you do, and usage-based pricing turns that gap into margin. You won’t close it with hardball. You close it with integrative negotiation, calibrated questions and a shared objective: a deal both sides would sign again.

  6. Leadership

    6. The senior job is making other people succeed.

    Early in a career, being the smartest person in the room is an asset. Later it becomes a tax on everyone else in it. The higher you go, the less your own answers matter and the more it matters whether the people around you can find theirs, including the ones with a real signal they can’t yet put into words. Standards matter more than brilliance, because standards outlive you.

    Behind this LegacySteve Jobs
  7. The human part

    7. Not everything worth doing should be optimised.

    I’m a systems person. I plan, track and measure most things, including my training. But the most useful reframe I’ve read recently wasn’t about doing more; it was about separating happiness from optimisation. Some things are worth doing for the doing. Chris Hoy’s account of facing a terminal diagnosis made the point better than any argument: as performance disappears, meaning remains.